3PL Vetting Toolkit
with the right questions.
Keep track of 70+ operational details and over 150 logistics questions that empower you to make informed decisions when choosing a 3PL for your fulfillment needs.
This tool, created by brand owners frustrated by their own 3PL hunts, distills years of conversations and learnings — designed to give you a clear, efficient path to choosing a fulfillment partner.
One decision framework.
Every section is structured around the questions a brand owner actually needs answered — not the questions a 3PL wants you to ask.
Operational Foundations
Warehouse footprint, hours of operation, peak-season capacity, and the structural questions that reveal whether a 3PL can scale with you.
Technology & Integrations
OMS, WMS, EDI, API capabilities, and the integrations that determine how cleanly your stack talks to theirs.
Fulfillment Mechanics
Pick rates, pack standards, SLAs, error rates, and the day-to-day mechanics that drive customer experience.
Inventory & Accuracy
Cycle counts, lot tracking, shrinkage policy, and the controls that protect your inventory truth.
Shipping & Carriers
Carrier mix, rate cards, dimensional weight rules, and the levers that determine your landed cost.
Returns & Reverse Logistics
RMA flow, restocking policy, grading standards, and how a 3PL handles the box that comes back.
Pricing & Contracts
Storage fees, pick fees, surcharges, minimums, and the contract terms that quietly compound over a year.
Account Management
Communication cadence, escalation paths, on-site presence, and the human layer behind the operation.
Built by brand owners who got burned.
Every founder we know has a 3PL horror story. The partner who promised 99% accuracy and delivered 92%. The warehouse that lost a pallet during peak. The account manager who stopped returning emails the week a Black Friday shipment went sideways.
We built this toolkit because we lived it. Every question in this sheet came from a real conversation, a real RFP, or a real post-mortem after a 3PL relationship went wrong.
The goal is simple: give you a structured way to compare 3PLs on the things that actually matter — before you sign a contract, not after.
Four steps from
shortlist to signature.
Duplicate the sheet
Open the template, then make a copy to your own Google Drive. Every question is editable — add your own as you go.
Send it to your shortlist
Pick the 3PLs you're seriously evaluating. Send the same sheet to each one so answers are directly comparable.
Score the responses
Use the built-in scoring columns to weight what matters most to your brand — speed, accuracy, cost, or account support.
Decide with confidence
Walk into your final calls with a side-by-side comparison and a clear view of the trade-offs you're actually making.
Vetting a 3PL?
Start with the right questions.
Grab the toolkit, send it to your shortlist, and walk into your final calls with a clear comparison. If you want a second opinion, Nice Commerce is one of the partners worth putting on that shortlist.
3PL Vetting Toolkit
70+ operational details. 150+ logistics questions. One Google Sheet.
Direct Download